by dougal » Tue May 09, 2006 9:55 am
I've just invested in this.
Yes its american (but it does have metric measurements as well as 'cups').
Yes, there's not much about *cold* smoking. (And almost nothing on smoking hardware.)
Yes, a few of the recipes aren't 'authentic' - for example the lamb/pork (rather than lamb/beef) "merguez".
And including salt cod and gravadlax as 'Charcuterie' is similarly loose - albeit brilliant to put those alongside bacon curing, to demonstrate the similarity.
And yes, they want to hot smoke the bacon, US/"Canadian" style.
No, it doesn't have any photo's - but there are photorealistic drawings which seem to perfectly illustrate the points they are addressing.
BUT -
I think the organisation is very rational. From salting and brining to smoking, then sausages (inc smoked ones), then on to dried meats and sausages, with a chapter on pat�s and one on accompaniments to close.
The writing is very lucid. (Thus far, I've only noticed a couple of lapses.)
The emphasis seems to be on communicating an understanding of the processes, rather than simply listing recipes.
I only got it a couple of days ago, so I'm reluctant to be too absolute, but it looks good. Damn good, in fact, for the thoughtful but inexperienced enthusiast - like me!
What do others think, now they've had it for a few months?