by Ianinfrance » Mon Jan 25, 2010 12:20 am
Hi Phil,
This has turned into rather a long answer. Sorry.
When you say "product" in that context, I presume you're referring to duck breast fillets rather than magrets. I've never seen any labels attached to magrets - but I'd not really expect to considering how I buy mine.
I'm afraid I have to say that I've no idea what kind of label gets applied to normal duck fillets. I'm not trying to be dismissive in any way, merely admitting to complete ignorance. I'm not trying to take any kind of moral high ground on this, but I buy magrets at Brive market from suppliers I've known for years and trust, and as part of a meal, they work out at around €4 per person. I vastly prefer them to ordinary duck, even for asian food, (though not at all authentic). So you see... I pass in front of the meat counters on which duck breast fillets are displayed without really looking at them.
I am a little cynical about most of the labels applied to foodstuffs in France, I'm afraid to say. I've got several good friends who are involved in the production of food (a veal farmer, a wine maker, veg growers, pork farmer , dairy farmer etc) and most of them tell me that the only thing the organizers of the labels are REALLY keen on is to ensure that they are paid for the producers' adhesion to the scheme. That's not to say that the ideals are unworthy, but often in reality, they aren't policed or that tough anyway. For example..... if you're worried about the foodstuffs given to chickens (recycling dead diseased birds is what led to the spread of salmonella in eggs) then I'm unimpressed by a label which says "fed on 90% grains and minerals" So what's the 10% then?
Where "Label Rouge" is useful in chicken production for example, is that they guarantee a minimum of 81 days before slaughter, which is WAY better than most chickens in the UK. (I don't know the comparable figures for other food animals).
I know that I'm incredibly privileged living in an area why I can really know just how my food animals are treated. It's one of the many reasons we fell in love with here.
I am sure that we could do the same if we lived in a rural area in the UK, by the way. But it really would be hard trying to find where your local butcher in Walthamstow sourced his pork and how the pigs were raised!
All the best - Ian
"The Earth is degenerating today. Bribery and corruption abound. Children no longer obey their parents, every man wants to write a book, and it is evident that the end of the world is fast approaching." c. 2800 BC